Interested in the cards and athletes that have been submitted for PSA grading from January to December 2023? Here’s a roundup with the top 10 cards and players that were submitted to PSA in 2023.

The most graded PSA players tend to give a good indication of which way the market is leaning, with plenty of cards sent to the most popular grading company over the course of the year.

We’ve listed the most graded players sent to PSA over the past 12 months, featuring some of the most popular athletes from a range of US sports.

Top 10 PSA Card Submissions 2023: Per Athlete 

We’ve listed the top 10 PSA sports card submissions, relating to the most graded players sent to PSA over the past 12 months. These athletes span across various sports, reflecting the diverse interests within the sports card collecting community. We’ve also looked at their most expensive PSA card sales via eBay:

1. Shohei Ohtani (eBay)

To the surprise of nobody, Shohei Ohtani takes the top spot, as the most graded player sent to PSA over the entirety of 2023. Baseball’s best player, ShoTime has a wealth of valuable cards to pick from, especially if they happen to be wrapped in a PSA slab. His dual-threat abilities as both a pitcher and hitter have captured the attention of fans and collectors alike.

Check out the best Shohei Ohtani rookie cards here.

2. Michael Jordan (eBay)

A name that is synonymous with the hobby, Michael Jordan cards are still worth their weight in gold. This is true of his rookie cards, as well as later editions that come with a small print run. Jordan’s impact on the game of basketball and popular culture ensures a lasting demand for his collectibles.

Check out the best Michael Jordan rookie cards here.

3. Julio Rodriguez (eBay)

Third on the list, Julio Rodriguez is another major name, with various cards that sell for major money. Rookie cards were released in 2021, while prospect cards can be found from 2017. The anticipation surrounding his career has driven collectors to seek out and grade his cards, contributing to his prominent placement on this list.

Check out the best Julio Rodriguez rookie cards here.

4. Trevor Lawrence (eBay)

Trevor Lawrence is the first in a string of QBs that have been sent for grading over the past 12 months. It’s no real surprise, given his high-profile entry into the NFL. The quarterback position always garners attention in the card-collecting world, and Lawrence’s potential as a franchise quarterback adds to the appeal of his graded cards.

5. Joe Burrow (eBay)

At the current time of writing Joe Burrow is out injured, and the QB tore his ACL and MCL in his left knee during his rookie season. Despite this setback, the demand for Burrow’s cards remains robust. His rookie cards continue to be hot commodities as collectors anticipate his return to the field.

Check out the best Joe Burrow rookie cards here.

6. Tom Brady (eBay)

Tom Brady is always going to be one of the biggest names in card collecting. His rarest cards have proven to be some of the most profitable, especially when looking at versions such as the 2000 Playoff Contenders Tom Brady RC.

Check out the best Tom Brady rookie cards here.

7. Kobe Bryant (eBay)

LeBron James is an icon within the sport of basketball, and his cards remain highly sought after. As one of the greatest players of his generation, LeBron’s impact on the game ensures a lasting appeal for his collectibles.

Check out the best Kobe Bryant rookie cards here.

8. LeBron James (eBay)

LeBron James is an icon within the sport of basketball, and his cards remain highly sought after. As one of the greatest players of his generation, LeBron’s impact on the game ensures a lasting appeal for his collectibles, including the 2003-04 Topps Chrome RC seen above. 

Check out the best LeBron James rookie cards here.

9. Ken Griffey Jr. (eBay)

When we looked at the best Ken Griffey Jr. cards back in 2022, we concluded:

“His collection of RCs might have been overproduced to the point of minor deforestation, but PSA 10 copies are still a valid long-term investment if you’re hoping for safer options within the hobby.”

Nothing has changed in the past 18 months, so it’s no surprise that many fans are still sending in Griffey Jr. cards, especially given there’s a continued belief in the long-term investment potential.

Check out the best Ken Griffey Jr. rookie cards here.

10. Patrick Mahomes II (eBay)

Last, but by no means least, Patrick Mahomes II has led the Kansas City Chiefs to five consecutive AFC Championship Game appearances, and is always popular with card collectors. 

As the youngest quarterback in NFL history to be named Super Bowl MVP, the future bodes well in terms of values, and he’s almost certain to be included in the Hall of Fame. Even with a slight lull in the market, PSA 10 versions of rarer Mahomes RCs can easily sell for five figures, as seen in the image above. 

Check out the top 10 Patrick Mahomes II rookie cards here.

Most Graded PSA Card Athletes 2023: Thoughts 

It’s a strong showing for US sports, featuring some of the biggest basketball, baseball, and American football stars on the planet. A PSA 10 grade is likely to be worth major money, especially if you’re looking at rookie cards for any of the popular athletes mentioned above. 

Most Graded PSA Card Athletes 2023: Summary  

In the world of sports card collecting, the PSA grading system holds significant weight. A PSA 10 grade indicates a card is in mint condition, free from any imperfections, and this can significantly impact the card’s market value. As we look back on the top 10 PSA card submissions of 2023, the dominance of certain athletes and sports is evident, reaffirming their iconic status within the hobby.

Shohei Ohtani’s presence at the top of the list comes as no surprise. The two-way sensation has captivated baseball fans with his remarkable pitching and hitting abilities. Ohtani’s cards, especially his rookie editions, have become highly sought after, and the PSA slabs only add to their allure.

Michael Jordan, despite retiring from professional basketball years ago, remains an enduring figure in the sports card market. His rookie cards, often considered holy grails of the hobby, continue to command high prices. The nostalgia associated with Jordan’s era and the scarcity of his early cards contribute to their enduring popularity.

Julio Rodriguez, a rising star in baseball, claims the third spot on our list. His rookie cards from 2021 and earlier prospect cards have seen increased submissions to PSA, reflecting the anticipation surrounding his promising career.

The quarterback contingent, represented by Trevor Lawrence and Joe Burrow, further demonstrates the enduring appeal of NFL players in the sports card market.