When to Get a Sports Card Graded

Hey there! This post contains affiliate links, which means we may get a commission at no extra cost to you. It helps to support the site, and has no impact on the cards we recommend or discuss. I greatly appreciate your support!

Navigating the world of sports card collecting can be an exciting journey. One key decision collectors often face is whether to get a sports card graded. Card grading is a process where a professional company evaluates a card’s condition, assigns it a grade, and encases it in a protective slab. This guide aims to provide insights into when it would be beneficial to get a sports card graded.

Understanding the Value of Graded Cards

Before deciding whether to grade a card, it’s crucial to understand the potential benefits of a graded card:

  1. Condition Verification: A graded card provides a clear, unbiased assessment of a card’s condition, which can be critical for determining its value.
  2. Marketability: Graded cards often command higher prices in the market, especially those in top conditions.
  3. Authenticity: Grading companies often verify the card’s authenticity, reducing the risk of counterfeits.
  4. Protection: Graded cards are encased in a protective slab, preserving their condition over time.

When to Consider Grading a Sports Card

While there’s no definitive rule, certain circumstances might make it beneficial to get a sports card graded:

  1. Value of the Card: If the card is valuable or rare, getting it graded can increase its worth and desirability among collectors.
  2. Condition: Cards that are in excellent condition are prime candidates for grading. A high grade can significantly enhance their value.
  3. Selling Intent: If you plan to sell a card, getting it graded can make it more appealing to buyers and potentially increase its selling price.
  4. Player’s Status: Cards featuring popular players or rising stars may benefit from grading as the player’s performance can influence the card’s value.
  5. Card Age: Older, vintage cards can benefit from grading, both for authenticity verification and to get an unbiased assessment of their condition.

Check Prices of PSA 10 Graded Cards on eBay

The Grading Process

Once you’ve decided to grade a card, understanding the grading process can help manage expectations and potential costs:

  1. Choosing a Grading Company: Companies like Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), Beckett Grading Services (BGS), and Sportscard Guaranty Corporation (SGC) are popular choices.
  2. Pricing and Turnaround: Costs can vary based on the card’s value, the service level chosen, and the grading company. Turnaround times can range from a few days to several months.
  3. Preparing Your Card: Ensure your card is properly cleaned and packaged before sending it for grading to avoid damage in transit.

Check Prices of PSA 10 Graded Cards on eBay

Exploring Smaller Grading Companies

While PSA, BGS, and SGC are the most well-known grading companies, several smaller grading services are also making their mark in the industry. These include:

  1. CGC (Certified Guaranty Company): Known primarily for their comic book grading, CGC has recently ventured into card grading. They offer competitive pricing and are gaining traction for their transparent and detailed grading process.
  2. GMA (Gem Mint Authentication): As one of the more economical options for grading, GMA may be a good choice for lower-value cards that wouldn’t justify the cost of a premium grading service.
  3. HGA (Hybrid Grading Approach): Combining AI technology with human expertise, HGA is creating buzz in the sports card industry. They offer unique, color-matched slabs that add a visual appeal to the graded card.
  4. CSG (Certified Sports Guaranty): A newer player in the sports card grading arena, CSG is already making a name for itself with its accurate grading and innovative holder design.
  5. KSA (KSA Certification): A Canadian-based grading company, KSA is recognized for their fair grading and excellent customer service.

While these smaller grading companies may not carry the same recognition or market value as PSA, BGS, or SGC, they can still offer value in certain circumstances. For example, they may be a more cost-effective choice for lower-value cards or provide faster turnaround times when the bigger companies are backlogged. However, it’s important to do your research and understand the potential market implications of using a lesser-known grading company.

The Cons of Grading a Sports Card

While grading has its advantages, it’s important to be aware of potential downsides:

  1. Costs: The grading process isn’t free. Depending on the card’s value and the turnaround time you want, the costs can add up, particularly if you’re grading multiple cards.
  2. Time: Grading can take time, ranging from a few days to several months. This delay could be a disadvantage if you’re looking to sell quickly.
  3. No Guarantee of High Grade: A card’s condition might look great to the naked eye, but under professional examination, small flaws could lead to a lower grade. It’s crucial to carefully examine your cards and set realistic expectations.

Deciding Not to Grade

There are instances where grading might not be the best option:

  1. Lower-Value Cards: For cards that aren’t particularly valuable, the cost of grading might exceed the potential increase in value.
  2. Cards in Played Condition: If a card shows signs of wear and tear, grading might not significantly improve its value.
  3. Personal Collection: If you’re collecting for personal enjoyment and have no plans to sell, you might not see the benefit in grading your cards.

Choosing a Grading Company

Different grading companies offer various benefits, and the choice can depend on your specific needs:

  1. PSA: Known for its straightforward grading scale and wide recognition in the industry. Great for vintage and modern cards.
  2. BGS (Beckett Grading Services): Recognized for their sub-grade system, which provides more detail about the card’s condition. Often favored for modern cards.
  3. SGC: Known for its fast turnaround times and customer service. Often used for vintage cards.

Choosing the right grading company depends on factors such as the type of card you’re grading, your budget, and the timeframe in which you need the card graded. Each company has its strengths, so it’s important to research and decide which is best for your needs.

Check Prices of PSA 10 Graded Cards on eBay


Choosing to grade a sports card is a strategic decision, contingent upon factors like the card’s condition, value, and the player’s status. It’s essential to do your research, understand the potential costs, and consider your long-term plans for the card. Remember, while grading can add value, it’s not necessary or beneficial for every card in your collection. As with all aspects of sports card collecting, enjoy the process and use grading as a tool to enhance your collecting experience.

Published by James Milin-Ashmore

Journalism gradate, freelance writer. Sports, tech, online security, collectibles.

Leave a ReplyCancel reply