With so many options to choose from, it’s hard to know which Tyler Herro rookie card is best. We’ve narrowed down the list to our top five selections.
Tyler Herro has been with the Miami Heat since 2019, reaching the NBA finals in his rookie year. Named the NBA Sixth Man of the Year in 2022, there’s no denying that he’s a superstar in the making.
It’s unsurprising that he’s one of the more popular players if you’re looking at RC values. Here’s a roundup with five of the best Tyler Herro rookie cards to collect, with lots of info about each option.
The Best Tyler Herro Rookie Cards
As Herro was drafted in the first round of 2019, that’s where you’ll find his rookie cards. Herro was included in a variety of inserts and cards, as well as various parallels released that year.
5. 2019-20 Panini One & One Downtown Tyler Herro RC #10 (eBay)
2019-20 Panini One and One Basketball is where you’ll find Herro’s premium Downtown insert. A new inclusion for the NBA that season, Downtown inserts were produced for 25 top players. Despite being unnumbered, Downtown inserts have proven to be one of the more popular NBA releases in recent years.
The unique design sees players set against a backdrop dedicated to their team and city. Typically falling at a rate of one per case, Downtown cards aren’t easy to find.
Check prices of 2019-20 Panini One & One Downtown Tyler Herro RC on eBay
4. 2019-20 Panini Spectra Color Blast Tyler Herro RC #5 (eBay)
2019-20 Panini Spectra Basketball is up next. The super short print Color Blast Prizm insert has been included in NBA Spectra sets since 2019-20. It contains a crisp white background set against vivid colors.
Herro’s Color Blast RC uses a landscape design, with a familiar Spectra logo in the top left corner. Once again, they’re extremely rare, falling at a rate of one in every 10 cases.
Check prices of 2019-20 Panini Spectra Color Blast Tyler Herro RC on eBay
3. 2019-20 Contenders Rookie Ticket Tyler Herro RC #142 (eBay)
Herro’s Rookie Ticket found in 2019-20 Panini Contenders Basketball is always a hit with collectors. It uses a traditional RT design, with various Ticket parallels, along with Premium Editions like the Gold version seen above.
It’s arguably the most popular Tyler Herro RC auto, unless you’re looking at one of the high-end sets seen below.
- Parallels: Playoff #/99, The Finals #/49, Cracked Ice #/25, Championship 1/1, Printing Plates 1/1
- Premium Edition parallels: Base, Green Shimmer, Blue Shimmer FOTL #/20, Gold #/10, Gold Vinyl 1/1
Check prices of 2019-20 Contenders Rookie Ticket Tyler Herro RC on eBay
2. 2019-20 Panini Flawless Tyler Herro RC #VPTHR (eBay)
2019-20 Panini Flawless Basketball is where you’ll find this premium RPA. The signature is on-card, and it comes with a medium-sized player patch next to an image of the shooting guard. In truth, any of the signed Herro RCs from the collection is worth a lot of scratch. The base version of the Vertical Patch Auto card seen above is limited to 25 copies. The majority of the other Herro RCs from the set are similarly scarce.
- Parallels: Ruby #/15, Gold #/10, Emerald #/5, Platinum 1/1
Check prices of 2019-20 Panini Flawless Tyler Herro RC on eBay
1. 2019-20 National Treasures Tyler Herro RC #132 (eBay)
The high-end 2019-20 National Treasures Basketball collection is where we finish up.
There are nine different Tyler Herro RCs found within the set, but we’ll stick with the popular Rookie Patch Autographs card seen above. It comes with a generously-sized swatch that takes up most of the space, and the patch is player-worn. There’s also a large on-card auto at the bottom, filled in blue ink. A big hit with collectors due to strong branding, many have already been sent off for grading.
- Parallels: Gold #/10, Emerald #/5, Logoman 1/1
- FOTL Parallels: Stars & Stripes #/30, Stars & Stripes Blue #/3
Check prices of 2019-20 National Treasures Tyler Herro RC on eBay
Why Are Tyler Herro Cards So Valuable?
Herro has been around for a few seasons, and it’s easy to forget that he’s still only 22 at the current time of writing. The potential for a Hall of Fame career is a driving force behind the high prices seen for his rarest rookie cards. A couple of All-Star appearances will cause values to rise even more, as he appears to be on the right path to success.
To give some idea of values at the upper end, the Gold parallel of the Tyler Herro Rookie Patch Autographs card recently sold for $8,988 via eBay:
Tyler Herro Rookie Cards: Final Thoughts
Herro has a ton of rookie cards to sift through, from base cards worth a couple of cents, to rare RPAs that sell for four figures. There’s something to suit almost every budget, while the player continues to improve with each passing season. It’s clear that many collectors think that he has what it takes for sustained success in the NBA.
He recently made history by becoming the first player to record nine or more three points on back-to-back nights, and scored a career-high 41 points against the Rockets. Herro became the youngest player in Heat history to have a 40-point game in the process, highlighting his ever-improving reputation on the court.