Bart Starr (1934-2019) is a Green Bay Packers legend, featuring as their quarterback, and later their head coach during a long association with the team. His playing career spanned from 1956–1971, and he served as their coach for a further eight years. 

Starr is the only quarterback in NFL history to lead a team to three consecutive league championships (1965–1967). The Hall of Famer also won MVP honors in both Super Bowls I and II.

Here’s everything you could possibly need to know about the Bart Starr rookie card, as we look at its investment potential. 

The Best Bart Starr Rookie Cards

There’s a sole Bart Starr rookie card, released by Topps way back in 1957. 

1. 1957 Topps Football Bart Starr RC #119 (eBay)

1957 Topps Football is a classic set, with cards split into two sections. The front of the card displays two pictures of the player. One is a profile image, with the other working as an action shot of sorts. 

They’re superimposed over colored blocks, using blue and orange as the background. The Bart Starr rookie card is seen as one of the keys to the set, and it’s dripping with vintage appeal. 

The reverse shares the landscape design, using the space for a brief bio, alongside the customary cartoons. 

Check prices of 1957 Topps Football Bart Starr RC on eBay 

Bart Starr Rookie Card: Buyers Guide 

Here’s what we think of the current shape of the market when looking at the 1957 Bart Starr rookie card. 

We’d opt for vintage rather than modern if you’re looking for more affordable options featuring the legendary quarterback. A great example would be the 1958 Topps Bart Starr card, released just a year after the RC. Check out some of the recent sale prices:

Check prices of 1958 Topps Football Bart Starr card on eBay

They sell for a fraction of the price compared to the 1957 card. 

In terms of pure investments, the Bart Starr rookie card is always going to be the most popular option. It’s his only true rookie card, released way back in 1957. According to the PSA pop report, a trio of 9 grades are the best copies you’ll find. 

In terms of values, expect to pay four figures for PSA 5 grades and over. A Mint 9 copy sold for an eye-watering $288,000 in 2017. 

Alternatively, signed cards from later years are another option favored by hardcore Packers fans. 

Bart Starr Rookie Cards: Final Thoughts 

A legendary player with a sole rookie card released as part of an iconic set, it’s easy to see the positives when looking at the Bart Starr 1957 RC. 

His rookie card is one of the best from the era, while the last recorded PSA 9 sale was over five years ago, for $288,000. Who knows what the price would have been during the height of hype in the hobby during 2021? We suspect the fee would still be higher in the present day. 

The Hall of Famer passed away in 2019 at the age of 85. His legacy as the first quarterback in history to win five National Football League championships and the hero of the most memorable game in the history of the Green Bay Packers is always going to be safe.